Homes and Cottages

Compare properties

The Blue House

62
Website: stayonki.com/properties/the-blue-house/ LOCATION, LOCATION, LOCATION. This 6 bedroom, 2 bathroom home eagerly awaits your ...
Website: stayonki.com/properties/the-blue-house/ LOCATION, LOCATION, LOCATION. This 6 bedroom, 2 bathroom home eagerly awaits your visit to Kelleys Island. Located in ...

KI Sunset Cottage

42
Website: stayonki.com/properties/ki-sunset-cottage/ KI Sunset Cottage rests on Kelleys Island’s far west side, looking straight ...
Website: stayonki.com/properties/ki-sunset-cottage/ KI Sunset Cottage rests on Kelleys Island’s far west side, looking straight out towards Put-In-Bay and Perry Monument. ...
member

Crafts Lakeview Lane

21
Cottage #1: Lakefront, two bedrooms, with three double beds, one single bed and a ...
Cottage #1: Lakefront, two bedrooms, with three double beds, one single bed and a single sofa bed. Cottages #2,3,4: Two ...
member

Sun and Surf

65.5
Website: www.sunandsurfohio.com 4 luxury rooms on the lake with private baths. House is fully ...
Website: www.sunandsurfohio.com 4 luxury rooms on the lake with private baths. House is fully air-conditioned. Direct tv is available in ...

Tootie’s Place

31
Breathtaking views. Imagine those moonlight walks and summer breezes that only an island can ...
Breathtaking views. Imagine those moonlight walks and summer breezes that only an island can make memorable. Just steps from downtown. ...

Changes In Latitude KI, LLC

32
This lakefront 3 bedroom/2 full bath home is newly remodeled and located just a ...
This lakefront 3 bedroom/2 full bath home is newly remodeled and located just a half mile from downtown Kelleys Island. ...

The Guest House

32
“The Guest House” is a 1500 square foot vacation rental located at 309 Harbor ...
“The Guest House” is a 1500 square foot vacation rental located at 309 Harbor Lane. This quiet neighborhood on the ...

Lookout Point Cottage

32
Website: stayonki.com/properties/lookout-point-cottage/ Newly updated 3 Bedroom, 2 Bath secluded lakeview vacation rental is located ...
Website: stayonki.com/properties/lookout-point-cottage/ Newly updated 3 Bedroom, 2 Bath secluded lakeview vacation rental is located in a private subdivision on island’s ...

Point of View Cottage

32
Website: A Point of View Cottage 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, DirectTV, Large hot tub, ...
Website: A Point of View Cottage 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, DirectTV, Large hot tub, secluded beach and much more… ...

Cozy Corner

43
Website: Cozy Corner Our home, equipped with 4 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms eagerly awaits ...
Website: Cozy Corner Our home, equipped with 4 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms eagerly awaits your visit to Kelleys Island. Constructed ...

Sweetbriar Retreat

32
Custom built in 2008, Sweetbriar Retreat is designed for the family who wants to ...
Custom built in 2008, Sweetbriar Retreat is designed for the family who wants to get away from it all and ...

Kelleys Lakeside II

53.5
Coming in 2018 — 1,400 sq. ft. putting green! If you are looking for ...
Coming in 2018 — 1,400 sq. ft. putting green! If you are looking for the ultimate rental home on beautiful ...

Kiki’s Cottage

32
Website: www.kikiscottage.com Kiki’s Cottage is one of Kelleys island newer cottage rentals. Built in ...
Website: www.kikiscottage.com Kiki’s Cottage is one of Kelleys island newer cottage rentals. Built in 2011 It has many features we ...

Morning Glory

42
Offering the charm of a restored century home and a long stretch of private ...
Offering the charm of a restored century home and a long stretch of private beach Morning Glory is able to ...
member

The Cliff House

42
The Cliff House is tucked away in a secluded central part of the island. ...
The Cliff House is tucked away in a secluded central part of the island. With an acre of land, the ...

Whitetail Retreat

32
Website: stayonki.com/properties/whitetail-retreat/ 3 bedrooms, 2 Full Bath Vacation Rental located on Private Road near ...
Website: stayonki.com/properties/whitetail-retreat/ 3 bedrooms, 2 Full Bath Vacation Rental located on Private Road near Kelleys Island Airport. Downstairs office has ...

Western Breeze

42
Website: stayonki.com/properties/western-breeze-lakefront-cottage/ Western Breeze Sunset Cottage rests on Kelleys Island’s far west side (Near ...
Website: stayonki.com/properties/western-breeze-lakefront-cottage/ Western Breeze Sunset Cottage rests on Kelleys Island’s far west side (Near the West Bay Inn). The Lakefront ...

BKs Beach House

32
Website: stayonki.com/properties/bks-beach-house/ This Beach House is Brand New! Over 100 feet of sand beach! ...
Website: stayonki.com/properties/bks-beach-house/ This Beach House is Brand New! Over 100 feet of sand beach! – 3 Bedroom, 2 Bath with ...

Zettler’s Lakefront

43
Website: Zettlers Lakefront Home Zettlers Lakefront Home is a charming turn-of-the century, completely renovated ...
Website: Zettlers Lakefront Home Zettlers Lakefront Home is a charming turn-of-the century, completely renovated Queen Anne home located on the ...

Sunset View Cottages

21
Lakefront furnished (no linens provided). Two cottages sleep six people each and one large ...
Lakefront furnished (no linens provided). Two cottages sleep six people each and one large cottage that sleeps twelve. The large ...

Island Time House

32
Newer 3 bedroom, 2 bath ranch style home with vaulted ceilings and open floor ...
Newer 3 bedroom, 2 bath ranch style home with vaulted ceilings and open floor plan. Great for entertaining and larger ...

The Barn

21
Unique new construction Kelleys Island rental – The Barn sleeps six, two bedrooms with ...
Unique new construction Kelleys Island rental – The Barn sleeps six, two bedrooms with one queen size bed and the ...
member

Carpe Diem Red

21
We have two lovely homes on a beautiful rolling hill surrounded by woods, fields, ...
We have two lovely homes on a beautiful rolling hill surrounded by woods, fields, hiking trails, the glacial grooves and ...

The Other House

52
Website: stayonki.com/properties/the-other-house/ Step Back in Time and Enjoy This 5 bedroom, 2 Full bath ...
Website: stayonki.com/properties/the-other-house/ Step Back in Time and Enjoy This 5 bedroom, 2 Full bath lakefront home built in 1875. Lake ...

Casa Del Sol

32
Casa Del Sol is a recently built Cape Cod situated at the end of ...
Casa Del Sol is a recently built Cape Cod situated at the end of a cul de sac on a ...

Docks Place

31
Docks Place is a 3 bedroom, 1 bath cottage with central air, kitchen, Living ...
Docks Place is a 3 bedroom, 1 bath cottage with central air, kitchen, Living room with a large yard approximately ...

Kiki’s Cabin

32
Website: www.kikiscabin.com Cabin Amenities • 2 bedrooms with KING size memory foam mattresses. Oversized ...
Website: www.kikiscabin.com Cabin Amenities • 2 bedrooms with KING size memory foam mattresses. Oversized Loft area with 2 KING sized ...
member

Carpe Diem White

21
We have two lovely homes on a beautiful rolling hill surrounded by woods, fields, ...
We have two lovely homes on a beautiful rolling hill surrounded by woods, fields, hiking trails, the glacial grooves and ...

Vistas al Mar

42.5
This house at 212 McGettigan is located on a fabulous waterfront lot on the ...
This house at 212 McGettigan is located on a fabulous waterfront lot on the east side of the island. Secluded ...

Downtown Flat

22
Website: stayonki.com/properties/downtown-flat/ Downtown Flat is the lower level unit of the “South Side School” ...
Website: stayonki.com/properties/downtown-flat/ Downtown Flat is the lower level unit of the “South Side School” which was built in 1853. This ...

Old Stone Place

32.5
Website: oldstoneplace.com The ideal Kelleys Island family vacation rental. Located across from the school ...
Website: oldstoneplace.com The ideal Kelleys Island family vacation rental. Located across from the school and library, Old Stone Place is ...

Buckleys Drydock

44
Come spend your time dry-docked with Buckley (52 lb. Alaskan King Salmon caught by ...
Come spend your time dry-docked with Buckley (52 lb. Alaskan King Salmon caught by the owner) at his luxurious island ...
member

Madonna’s Lakefront

21
Madonna’s Lakefront Cottage is a getaway delight located minutes from downtown, on the southeast ...
Madonna’s Lakefront Cottage is a getaway delight located minutes from downtown, on the southeast corner of the island. With beautiful ...

KI Cape Cod

42
Website: stayonki.com/properties/ki-cape-cod/ This home is equipped with 4 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms. Our ...
Website: stayonki.com/properties/ki-cape-cod/ This home is equipped with 4 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms. Our home is strategically located and ideally ...

Quarry Lake Cabin

32
Escape to the Quarry Lake Cabin and ease into island life. This beautiful, newer ...
Escape to the Quarry Lake Cabin and ease into island life. This beautiful, newer home has two bedrooms plus a ...

Kelleys Island Cottage

32
Thanks for visiting the webpage! The “Kelleys Island Cottage” is a 3 bedroom rental ...
Thanks for visiting the webpage! The “Kelleys Island Cottage” is a 3 bedroom rental home on Kelleys Island. We are ...
member

Kelleys Lake House

42
Take a deep breath and relax. We have you covered. Imagine a beach fire ...
Take a deep breath and relax. We have you covered. Imagine a beach fire on a starry night. You’re almost ...

Back in Time

32
Website: stayonki.com/properties/back-in-time/ LOCATION IS KEY – “BACK IN TIME COTTAGE” is a fully-equipped Historical ...
Website: stayonki.com/properties/back-in-time/ LOCATION IS KEY – “BACK IN TIME COTTAGE” is a fully-equipped Historical Island Home located in The Heart ...

A Shore Thing

31
Website: stayonki.com/properties/a-shore-thing/ Fully equipped 2 Bedroom with Loft and one bath Waterfront Cottage is ...
Website: stayonki.com/properties/a-shore-thing/ Fully equipped 2 Bedroom with Loft and one bath Waterfront Cottage is located on Southeast side of Island. ...
member

Hauser House

42
The Hauser House is a 2-story, 4 bedroom home located on the S.W. corner ...
The Hauser House is a 2-story, 4 bedroom home located on the S.W. corner of Division & Bookerman. The home ...

KI Hideaway

53
Website: stayonki.com/properties/ki-hideaway/ This home is equipped with 5 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms. This home ...
Website: stayonki.com/properties/ki-hideaway/ This home is equipped with 5 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms. This home is strategically located and ideally situated ...

Annalee’s Cottage

21
The perfect vacation spot! Step into a time gone by – wicker chairs on ...
The perfect vacation spot! Step into a time gone by – wicker chairs on the porch, gentle lake breezes, warm ...

Z Place 2 B

22
Built in 2000, Z PLACE 2 B is a beautiful two bedroom home located ...
Built in 2000, Z PLACE 2 B is a beautiful two bedroom home located in a quiet setting in a ...

Kaufman Kottage

32.5
Welcome to the Kaufman Kottage. This spacious family home is located at 417 Sweetvalley ...
Welcome to the Kaufman Kottage. This spacious family home is located at 417 Sweetvalley Lane, halfway between downtown and the ...
member

Kelleys Lakeside

43
Call now to book for 2018! Nestled on an acre of lakefront property on ...
Call now to book for 2018! Nestled on an acre of lakefront property on beautiful Kelleys Island, this gorgeous four-bedroom/three-full ...
member

Sandy Beach House

42.5
Lovingly restored century home with four bedrooms and two-and-a-half baths promises to make your ...
Lovingly restored century home with four bedrooms and two-and-a-half baths promises to make your island stay a memorable experience. Sandy ...
member

Lodge on the Lake

42
This is a house rental only. Come and relax in a lakefront paradise. Lake ...
This is a house rental only. Come and relax in a lakefront paradise. Lake views from all bedrooms and sunroom. ...

An Island Oasis

42.5
Bright and Airy Home with Waterviews Relax and rejuvenate in this exceptional 4 bedroom, ...
Bright and Airy Home with Waterviews Relax and rejuvenate in this exceptional 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath home with air conditioning ...

Cottage on Sunset

21
Comfortable and private, this is your home away from home on Kelleys Island. • ...
Comfortable and private, this is your home away from home on Kelleys Island. • 2 Bedrooms that sleep 6 very ...

Andy’s Place

22
Website: www.leisureworldvacationrentals.com Awaiting your arrival is a two bedroom, two bath Lake Erie vacation ...
Website: www.leisureworldvacationrentals.com Awaiting your arrival is a two bedroom, two bath Lake Erie vacation rental able to accommodate a 2-4 ...

Summer Wind

31.5
Private cottage comfortably decorated with a cathedral ceiling and bright, open floor plan. The ...
Private cottage comfortably decorated with a cathedral ceiling and bright, open floor plan. The home is located on a quiet, ...

South Point Cottage

32
Website: stayonki.com/properties/south-point-cottage/ Fully equipped 3 Bedroom, 2 bath Waterfront Cottage is located on Southside ...
Website: stayonki.com/properties/south-point-cottage/ Fully equipped 3 Bedroom, 2 bath Waterfront Cottage is located on Southside of Island, just east of Seaway ...

Goldeneye Hideaway

21
Website: Goldeneye Hideaway Pet-friendly 2 Bedroom, 1 bath w/ loft, sleeps a maximum of ...
Website: Goldeneye Hideaway Pet-friendly 2 Bedroom, 1 bath w/ loft, sleeps a maximum of six persons. House is located on ...

The Getaway

32
Website: www.leisureworldvacationrentals.com Welcome to The Getaway on Kelleys Island The 1,450 square feet of ...
Website: www.leisureworldvacationrentals.com Welcome to The Getaway on Kelleys Island The 1,450 square feet of The Getaway vacation rental offers 3 ...
member

Pleasant View

11
Pleasant View Cottages has six weekly rentals on beautiful Lake Erie. With amazing views ...
Pleasant View Cottages has six weekly rentals on beautiful Lake Erie. With amazing views of the sunset and mainland from ...

The Upper Deck

32
Website: stayonki.com/properties/the-upper-deck/ The Upper Deck is located in the upstairs unit of Kelleys Island’s ...
Website: stayonki.com/properties/the-upper-deck/ The Upper Deck is located in the upstairs unit of Kelleys Island’s only Downtown Rental Property. This 3 ...

201 – The Lakeshore

42
MILLION DOLLAR LAKE VIEW! Beautifully Updated Home On The South Shore Gorgeous 4 bedroom, ...
MILLION DOLLAR LAKE VIEW! Beautifully Updated Home On The South Shore Gorgeous 4 bedroom, two bath home on the south ...

House on the Lake

31.5
At House on the Lake, it is just you and the lake. House on ...
At House on the Lake, it is just you and the lake. House on the Lake is a three bedroom ...

The Great Escape

11
A small refurbished cottage with old island charm and new carpet and kitchen amenities. ...
A small refurbished cottage with old island charm and new carpet and kitchen amenities. Native stone bathroom and unique views ...

Dingers Den

32
Dinger’s Den is a three bedroom, two full bath home located on a private ...
Dinger’s Den is a three bedroom, two full bath home located on a private road on the east side of ...