| Above the Rest | Quarry Vista Lodge | Kelleys Island Retreat | Crafts Lakeview Lane |
| Kaufman Kottage | Captain Ron's Get-Away | The Captains Quarters | Old Stone Place |
| Doctors House | O'Boyles Retreat | Relatively Home | Weekend at Bernie's |
| Sandy Beach House | The Fox Den | Memory Manor | Docks Place |
| Cottage on Sunset | A Point of View Cottage | Zettler's Lakefront Home | Sandy Cove |
| House On The Lake | House on Lincoln | Marges Lakefront | The Old Nest |
| Kelleys Island Cottage | The Guest House | Bumblebee Cottage | Fairview Cottage |
| Z Place 2 B | Hoelzer's Holiday House | Kelley's Cozy Corner | Lower Cliff Lodge |
| Adagio Retreat | Dot's Place | The Cliff House | The Crows Nest |
| Nautica Blue | Buckley's Drydock | House in the Woods | The Woodland Cottage |
| Cedar Cottage | Little House | An Island Oasis | Hauser House |
| Dinger's Den | South Point Cottage | Sunset View Cottages | Tooties Place |
| Dick's Last Resort | Pleasant View | Sun Haven | Captain Bob's Lake House |